Limitations of Bird Scarers for Deer Control, Do They Work?

Limitations of Bird Scarers for Deer Control, Do They Work?

In the sphere of wildlife management, the quest for effective deer control methods is perpetual. Among the techniques, bird scarers have often been used with the hope of deterring deer from crops and land. However, bird scarers predominantly fall short when it comes to deer deterrence. Initially, they may cause a minor stir among the deer population, but over a short span, deer become accustomed to the noise, rendering bird scarers ineffective.

Bird scarers function by generating loud, startling noises intended to frighten birds, keeping them at bay. They aim to create an inhospitable environment for the birds, deterring them from encroaching on the area. However, deer exhibit a remarkable level of adaptability and tend to acclimate to the noises generated by bird scarers swiftly. Once the initial surprise wears off, deer discern these noises as non-threatening, thus, ignoring them.

The use of bird scarers is governed by specific guidelines as delineated by the NFU Bird Scarers Code of Practice on the National Farmers' Union (NFU) website.

https://www.nfuonline.com/updates-and-information/protecting-your-crop-nfu-bird-scarers-code-of-practice/ 

These guidelines are crafted to minimize nuisances and disturbances to people and domestic animals and encompass:

Operating Times: Bird scarers should only be operated from dawn to dusk, with some additional restrictions during weekends and public holidays.
Noise Levels: The noise level at the boundary of the nearest noise-sensitive premises should not exceed 85 decibels.
Location and Direction: Bird scarers should be positioned as far away as possible from such premises and should not be directed towards them.
Maintenance: Bird scarers should be well-maintained to ensure they operate correctly.
Alternation and Relocation: Bird scarers should be moved regularly to avoid habituation by birds.

However, these guidelines don’t translate effectively when the target is deer, not birds. The stringent restrictions on operating times, noise levels, and locations could further impede the effectiveness of bird scarers in deer management.

The inadequacies of bird scarers call for a more nuanced approach toward deer management. Wildscape Deer Management offers tailored deer management solutions that delve into the behavioural patterns and ecology of deer:

Thorough Site Assessment: Conducting exhaustive site assessments to comprehend the deer population dynamics, their impact, and the broader ecological context.
Customized Culling Plans: Designing and executing culling plans that are synchronized with the ecological and operational dynamics of the area in focus.
Habitat Management: Implementing habitat management practices aimed at deterring deer incursion and promoting a balanced ecosystem.
Monitoring and Adaptive Management: Utilizing ongoing monitoring and adaptive management strategies to ensure the effectiveness and sustainability of our deer management endeavors.

Our approach is deeply rooted in a profound understanding of deer ecology and the operational requirements of the landowners and farmers we serve. By collaborating with Wildscape Deer Management, stakeholders can adeptly navigate the intricacies of deer management, ensuring a balanced co-existence between human activities and the natural milieu.

The shortcomings of bird scarers underscore the imperative for a more informed, strategic approach to deer management. With specialized deer management services, landowners and farmers are better equipped to address the challenges posed by deer populations in a sustainable and efficient manner.

Back to blog
1 of 3